Few bands can survive being dropped by a major label. Usually they just flail around for a few years, trying to live the life of excessive waste and superficial spending that they were living and end up disbanding, never to be heard from again. Few Indie Rock bands can right songs with big hooks and power chords that reek of the nineties and get away with it. Nada Surf realizes that, so they give you just a few of those pop masterpieces and a whole lot of extremely succesful interpretation on their new record Lucky (Barsuk – February 5th).
The album opens with See These Bones, a dark affair that relies on sparsely picked minor chord guitars, backup vocals from Harvey Danger’s Sean Nelson and Death Cab’s Ben Gibbard, some sweeping strings, and a cautionary tale. Not wasting much time cheering you up, the trio then treats you to the pop gem that is Whose Authority with all of it’s sing along, shimmery goodness. A few tracks later the New Yorkers get all Crosby, Stills, & Nash on your un-expecting self with the wonderful Here Goes Something; full of descending three part harmonies, reverb treated tambourines, and an all too short running time. Similarly, The Film Did Not Go Round, is probably the prettiest song Matthew Caws has written to date with an arpeggio’d acoustic guitar, perfect female backing vocals, and a ridiculously sad narrative.
After a few more trademark guitar anthems, Are You Lighting? enters with it’s unexpected slide guitars, and general twanginess to sadden things back up and leave you wondering how you ignored them so long.
You could say that Lucky is the album for the Nada Surf fan that did’t know they were a Nada Surf fan, but that’s not entirely fair. The band didn’t as much re-invent themselves as they did improve upon an already successful formula. I don’t “Grade” albums around here because, frankly, who am I to do so, but if I did this one would clock in somewhere between “pre-order it right this second” and “seriously, I’m not kidding, right now.”
[mp3] Nada Surf – Are You Lightning?
Buy it (when it’s available) at Barsuk
Catch a Nada Surf show